Compare Paddles
Quick verdict
Main split: Soft feel-leaning (Tyson McGuffin Magnus 3S 16mm Pickleball Paddle) vs Pop-leaning (Black Opal).
Based on available specs; some data is missing.
Some specs are missing; comparisons may be limited.
Decision shortcuts
If you want softer feel, start with Tyson McGuffin Magnus 3S 16mm Pickleball Paddle (thicker core).
If you want pop-leaning response, start with Black Opal (thinner core).
Best-for highlights
Key differences
- Thickness: Black Opal is thinner by 2mm (14 mm vs 16 mm) — often feels firmer and more pop-leaning.
- Length: Tyson McGuffin Magnus 3S 16mm Pickleball Paddle is longer by 5mm (16.5 in (419 mm) vs 16.3 in (414 mm)) — adds reach and leverage.
- Face material: Diamon Tough Raw Carbon Fiber vs Carbon Fiber
Tradeoffs
Pop vs soft feel: Thinner cores tend to feel firmer and pop-leaning; thicker cores lean softer.
These paddles differ in price, thickness, dimensions, grip and materials.
Differences of ≥5g weight, ≥1mm thickness, ≥$20 price, or any material change
Pricing
Prices from Australian retailers. Range reflects different colorways and retailers.
Thickness
Dimensions
Grip
Materials
How we detect differences
We highlight specs as "different" when they exceed these thresholds:
- Weight: 0.2 oz (5g) or more difference
- Thickness: 1mm or more difference
- Price: $20 or more difference
- Materials: Any difference in core or face material